This is no place to live. Winter engulfs the city half of the year, burying it in snowdrifts, sheets of ice, and the frozen slush of decaying leaves, mud, oil from vehicles mixed with last week’s snowfall. Men and women bundled up in coats in early mornings slog their way downtown in single occupancy vehicles, hands clutching the steering wheel to prevent their slide onto oncoming traffic. Traveling east in the morning, the sun blinds the eye so that traffic signals are indiscernible, and we drive with the flow of traffic, squinting as we look for signals from other drivers to stop or pass. No children play in the streets without sidewalks. I have never seen such large potholes in my life.
I first came to Albany on a steamy August afternoon when the car air conditioning at full blast could not keep me from feeling dehydrated and nauseous. From Springfield, Massachusetts to Albany, New York I drove through the Berkshires on Interstate 90 where the speed limit is 65 miles per hour but everyone goes 80. I met with very few cars, more often trucks, and the landscape contained only rocks, cliffs, and forests. Only exit signs at great intervals indicated any sign of human habitation: Amherst, Lee, Pittsfield, all in Massachusetts. At night this highway is entire dark without any streetlights to illuminate the way ahead. Then out of the wilderness, without any preamble, the skyline of Albany bursts upon the driver, a dance of light hovering over the Hudson River, a capital city in the middle of nowhere, a metropolis isolated unto itself.
I knew that Albany was an old city, but that did not prepare me for the state of disrepair which greeted me. The South End, directly adjacent to the towering structures of the downtown office buildings, was a ghetto of boarded up storefronts, disheveled residences, and vacant lots. A Pepsi can rolled next to a trash receptacle on the street. A whole townhouse collapsed between two others, its foundation a rubble of dust and concrete. On Central Avenue, the city’s main commercial thoroughfare, I stop to find something to eat. A “For Rent” sign is displayed prominently on the door of what used to be the only Mexican restaurant in the city. The Chinese and Indians are faring better. A group of young black men standing around on a stoop stare at me. It makes me so uncomfortable that I get back in my car and drive up the street, only to be encountered by another group of young Asian men this time, sitting idly on a stoop and staring at me with a fixation that made me feel foreign and objectified. I ate lunch at a hole in the wall Chinese restaurant. I spend the afternoon checking out apartments in the city. At one place, the landlord did not show up for half an hour. When he arrived, he showed me into dank apartments that smelled of cooking gas, the floorboards were slanted, and the pipes in the bathroom were all rusted then painted over. I vomited on the sidewalk from heat and exhaustion.
The next day I spent exploring the city. I went to the State Museum. In the middle of the 20th century, infrastructure tore into historic neighborhoods in the name of progress and convenience. Coveted riverfront neighborhoods now survive as ghettos in the shadow of highway ramps. I checked out the Rockfeller Plaza. Its starkness and monumentality was such a contrast to the rest of the city that I felt as if I was standing in a postcard rather than in a real place. Rows of concrete towers rising on either side of the plaza had such stark silhouettes it was difficult to imagine humans working in them. Around the plaza, historic buildings, once handsome with cornices and moldings, crumble in disrepair, roofs punctured by falling snow, windows boarded up and silent. The palatial capitol, so impressive and ornate at a distance, is so battered that a crane stands by all year to fix it. The crane has been there so long that another crane is being employed to fix the crane.
I wondered whose idea it was to build a city here. The Dutch settlers who came to inhabit this place sailed up the Hudson River from Manhattan in search of—What? Beaver, timber, the desire to know what is up the river. Already Manhattan was a merciless metropolis, full of pestilent streets and colliding traffic. How they must have marveled at the primeval forests, lush with maple, hickory, oak and hemlock; alive with deer, moose, coyote and bobcats. The native people living here planted beans and squash in small clearings and hunted excess game. To the Europeans, the forest was a stubborn, unprofitable wasteland that needed to be cleared and cultivated in order to be made of value. They cut trees, surveyed and divided up the land, trapped beaver, built a fort to protect their meager outpost. When the winter arrived it was drowned in snow. Hundreds died.
Not for freedom from kings, creeds or religion did they come. Not for the beauty of the land or a sense of adventure. They came for pure greed, to rob the river of beavers and muskrats, to unearth the minerals hidden in the mountains, to burn and log the timber, to conquer and cultivate the land. Here they established a capital for a great commerce state. From here they blazed the trail of empire to Buffalo, Cleveland, and Chicago. Beverwyck, Albany’s original name—the first gateway to the West.
The clock on State Street beneath the Capitol rotates between displays of the time and the temperature. 4.55pm. 5 degrees Fahrenheit. The sound of church bells announces the end of the work day and civil servants flock out of the towers. Those who can afford it flee in their cars to the suburbs; those who cannot wait to be picked up by the bus. Someone starts to smoke inside the bus shelter, the smell drives me onto the sidewalk covered in a layer of ice. In half an hour, the downtown is deserted like a devastated ghost town. The Rockefeller Plaza shines like the surface of the moon on a raised platform like some enormous sacrificial alter, utterly disconnected from its surroundings, its underground concourse accessible only to those who arrive from within. Not even pigeons come to pick up the leftovers of this barren landscape.
I know I came here to make a change in the city, but I too want to leave and find an America less segregated, less positive that progress is defined by consumption. Then I remember that so many cities are settled in this way. The cycle of plunder, prosperity, decline, and sometimes revival is played out all over the globe. San Francisco, founded by Spaniards hunting for gold and converts; Buenos Aires, a colony in the South; the mining towns of the West, abandoned as quickly as they were founded; Dubai and the Middle East, prospering off of their last nonrenewable resource in the desert; cities built without any thought for the future, only the expectation that the children will find new lands to conquer, new peoples to subdue, new corners of the Earth to ravish, the planet inexhaustible as salt in the sea, the history of the New World.
But the children have not left. In this city, they planted tulips in front of the Capitol. They built schools and hospitals. They made parks and playgrounds, movie theaters and museums. Parents drive with their children through Christmas lights in Washington Park. In the summer, the lunar plaza lures employees afterhours with the sounds of “Alive at Five.” A fire breaks out in an old warehouse. A nanotech center mushrooms on the outskirts of town. A meditation and yoga studio grows in place of a church. This was never meant as a place to live. Yet we still live here.